Sample Proposal Analysis
Individually:
1. Make a list of two strengths and two weaknesses of each of the samples.
2. Rank these proposals in terms of how well they make their argument. Assume that you were actually evaluating these proposals for real change.
3. Post it to your individual blog.
Course Requirement: Extortion
Strengths
1. Catchy title.
2. Explains the topic well.
3. Explains why previous solutions are inadequate.
Weaknesses
1. Uses topic-specific vocabulary without explanation.
2. Could include what students would realistically have to pay of his plan were put into effect.
Off-Campus Spending
Strengths:
1. Clearly outlines what the problem is, what the solution would be, and how the change would benefit both the students and the university.
2. Clear, professional organization of the paper.
Weakness:
1. Does not include evidence to back up the claims that her proposal is based upon (women eat less than men, or enough so that the current policy discriminates against them).
2. Uses herself as an example, references other universities but does not specify which universities or how they enact their policies.
Nuclear Power
Strengths:
1. Addresses opposing arguments.
2. Several reliable sources and statistics.
Weaknesses:
1. Make a list of two strengths and two weaknesses of each of the samples.
2. Rank these proposals in terms of how well they make their argument. Assume that you were actually evaluating these proposals for real change.
3. Post it to your individual blog.
Course Requirement: Extortion
Strengths
1. Catchy title.
2. Explains the topic well.
3. Explains why previous solutions are inadequate.
Weaknesses
1. Uses topic-specific vocabulary without explanation.
2. Could include what students would realistically have to pay of his plan were put into effect.
Off-Campus Spending
Strengths:
1. Clearly outlines what the problem is, what the solution would be, and how the change would benefit both the students and the university.
2. Clear, professional organization of the paper.
Weakness:
1. Does not include evidence to back up the claims that her proposal is based upon (women eat less than men, or enough so that the current policy discriminates against them).
2. Uses herself as an example, references other universities but does not specify which universities or how they enact their policies.
Nuclear Power
Strengths:
1. Addresses opposing arguments.
2. Several reliable sources and statistics.
Weaknesses:
Comments
Post a Comment